INDUSTRIAL FARM ANIMAL PRODUCTION: The cost of corn-fed cattle

Cattle fed on a heavy diet of corn will eventually become sick and die. Via a transcript from Fresh Air with Terry Gross (emphasis added):

GROSS: Let’s get back to the cow’s stomach.

Mr. POLLAN: Yeah.

GROSS: So the cow now is eating corn instead of eating grass. Its stomach is made for digesting grass and turning it into protein. How does the cow’s digestive system handle corn?

Mr. POLLAN: Well, very poorly. It’ll go kablooey if it’s not done very gradually. And I talked to people who said that most cows, most beef cattle getting a heavy diet of corn–and again, they can tolerate some of it, but when you crank it up to 70, 80, 90 percent grain, their stomachs go haywire. They suffer from a range of different phenomenon, one of which is bloat.

You know, the rumen, this organ, is always producing copious amounts of gas, and these are expelled during rumination, you know, when the animal kind of chews its cud. It regurgitates this bolus of grass and in the process releases all this greenhouse gas, essentially methane and things because when you’re digesting grass much gas is produced. But when they’re eating corn, this layer of slime forms over the mass in the rumen, and it doesn’t allow the gas to escape. So what happens is the rumen begins to expand like a balloon until it’s pressing up against the lungs of the animal. And if nothing is done to release the pressure of that gas, the animal suffocates. It can’t breathe anymore. So what do they do? Well, if it gets to that point, they force a hose down the esophagus of the animal, and that releases the gas, and they very quickly put them back on hay for a little while.

So that’s one of the things that can go wrong. Well, perhaps the most dramatic. But a whole other range of problems are created because the corn acidifies the rumen. The rumen has basically a neutral pH when it’s healthy and getting grass, and that’s very significant for a lot of reasons. But you feed it corn and it gets a lot more acidic. And the rumen can’t deal with acids, and what happens is the acids gradually eat away at the wall of the rumen, creating little lesions or ulcers through which bacteria can pass. And the bacteria get into the bloodstream and travel down to the liver, which collects all such impurities, and infects the liver. And that is why more than 13 percent of the animals slaughtered in this country are found to have abscessed livers that have to be thrown away and is a sign of disease.

But this low-level sickness, acidosis or even subacute acidosis, as they call it, afflicts many, many–probably the majority–of feedlot calves, and it leaves them vulnerable to all sorts of other diseases. Their immune systems are compromised. So they get this, you know, horrifying list of feedlot diseases. You know, we have these diseases of civilization, you know, heart disease and such things. Well, they have their own diseases of civilization: feedlot polio, abscessed livers, rumenitis, all these kinds of things that cows in nature simply don’t get.

GROSS: Is this where the antibiotics come in?

Mr. POLLAN: Yeah. The only way you can keep a cow alive getting this much corn would be with antibiotics. And they get large quantities of antibiotics with their feed every day. They get rumensin, which is technically an ionophore. It’s a kind of antibiotic that helps with the bloat and the acidosis. And then they get tylosin, which is in the erythromycin family. And that antibiotic cuts down on the incidence of liver disease, and without that, they would all have liver disease probably.

So, you know, when people debate antibiotics in livestock, which is a very, you know, important issue, and it’s before the Congress right now, they make this easy distinction between feeding animals antibiotics to promote growth, which is done in the chicken industry and the pig industry, and then feeding them when they’re sick, which even the public health advocates against using antibiotics in livestock say, ‘Of course it’s fine. You must treat sick animals.’ But where do you put the beef calf who is clearly getting these antibiotics to cure him? On the other hand, he wouldn’t be sick if we weren’t feeding him what we feed him? So it kind of confounds the usual distinction. If you took away these antibiotics, everything would have to change.

GROSS: Michael Pollan’s article on the beef industry was published in Sunday’s New York Times Magazine. His book, “The Botany of Desire,” will be published in paperback next month. We’ll talk more about the beef industry in the second half of the show. I’m Terry Gross, and this is FRESH AIR.

(Announcements)

GROSS: Coming up, the consequences of feeding cattle antibiotics and hormones. We continue our conversation with Michael Pollan about the modern industrial steak.

(Soundbite of music)

GROSS: This is FRESH AIR. I’m Terry Gross, back with Michael Pollan. We’re talking about how cattle are raised and fed in today’s industrialized beef industry. Michael Pollan’s article, This Steer’s Life, was the cover story of last Sunday’s New York Times Magazine. He usually writes about gardening and organic food. His book “The Botany of Desire: A Plants-Eye View of the World” will be published in paperback next month. When we left off, we were talking about why cattle are fed antibiotics along with their corn feed. Well, the corn wreaks havoc on the cow’s digestive system. The digestive problems are addressed with antibiotics.

Now what about the effects of the antibiotics on we humans that eat the cow meat? Is there still antibiotic residue in the meat?

Mr. POLLAN: Yes, they have found recently that there are antibiotic residues. But the larger problem–and this is one of the key connections between their health and our health, which I believe you simply can’t separate–is that simply by putting this huge quantity of these antibiotic chemicals into the environment–you know, more than half of the antibiotics made in this country go to feed livestock–you are creating resistant bugs, resistant bacteria. This is how evolution works. If you put a poison in the environment, to a population, it will evolve to withstand that poison. And that is happening. And that can be proven. It happens downstream of feedlots in the water that’s getting away. It happens in the manure of the animals.

In their digestive tract, right now, they are selecting for strains of bacteria that can withstand erythromycin, that can withstand penicillin, and those bacteria, having been created through this process, are now everywhere. And there is a connection between the antibiotics that steer number 534 is getting, and all his pen mates, and the fact that when my son has an ear infection, I have a hell of time finding an antibiotic now that will work. The reason that our antibiotics are failing is in part because we are squandering them on all these animals.

Video: Feeding cattle fast food: Some farmers are feeding their cattle a mixture of M&Ms or chocolate and potato chips in addition to the corn-based feed. I imagine the chocolate and potato chips aren’t satisfactory to market or suitable for human consumption.

On the Net:

  1. This Steer’s Life
  2. Diet And Disease In Cattle: High-Grain Feed May Promote Illness And Harmful Bacteria
  3. Junk Food In, Junk Food Out: Ethanol, Corn Prices and the Declining Quality of American Beef
  4. Power Steer
Advertisement

9 thoughts on “INDUSTRIAL FARM ANIMAL PRODUCTION: The cost of corn-fed cattle

  1. This is disgusting. Between high-fructose corn syrup and this crap, it’s no wonder Americans keep getting fatter and fatter and fatter… with a massive increase in Diabetes. Not to mention, it’s like the American public continues to become dumber as time goes on… Besides being uneducated, their brains are malnourished. These farmers should be ashamed of themselves. They’re disgraceful, as is their treatment of their livestock. And I think it’s criminal against the American public.

    Thank you for posting this.

    • WHooooooaaa take it is Sir or Ma’am, not all Americans are dumb as you think, and not all Americans are fat either, I understand your frustration, but i am an American and proud to be one i must say. I am 6’2 215lbs, In the Military and I think i am in decent shape if I might add. But i do disagree with you, I am disgusted at the way Americans are sitting by and not saying or doing anything about this. Is it because they are uninformed or is it because they just dont care, Who knows, but please dont put all americans in the same boat, thank you.

  2. Pingback: » Meat protein with a side of junk food & antibiotics, anyone? - Mom Goes Green

  3. Javron :WHooooooaaa take it is Sir or Ma’am, not all Americans are dumb as you think, and not all Americans are fat either, I understand your frustration, but i am an American and proud to be one i must say. I am 6’2 215lbs, In the Military and I think i am in decent shape if I might add. But i do agree with you, I am disgusted at the way Americans are sitting by and not saying or doing anything about this. Is it because they are uninformed or is it because they just dont care, Who knows, but please dont put all americans in the same boat, thank you.

  4. Pingback: King Corn « CHMP

  5. Hi I would like to know its cattle industry I am a student of the career of medina veterinary and animal husbandry of the Universidad Michoacana de San Nicolás de Hidalgo. I need to know his ranch
    Escuchar
    Leer fonéticamente
    Diccionario – Ver diccionario detallado

  6. Hi I would like to know its cattle industry I am a student of the career of medina veterinary and animal husbandry of the Universidad Michoacana de San Nicolás de Hidalgo. I need to know his ranch

  7. Hi everyone that is not in the cattle industry i would like to inform you on a few key facts that would help you truly understand what practices we do to feed our cattle to usda standers.
    !. The cattle industry does feed corn but to a certain extent they do not just poor corn for them to eat they have formulated it so they can develop and grow to market standers. They have feed formulated with roughage and other nutritional things so they grow and develop.
    2. If you knew something about cattle you would know if you just feed corn to cattle you should know that it does cause this disease and problem with them not able to let the gas release. But there are other problems that occur when you do this is that your feed becomes too “hot” meaning no weight gain. so if you owned a business would you really want the wellbeing of your animals to have no weight gain. I think not!
    3. Another misconception of the ignorate public that only read articles that have some facts but not a whole over view.
    So you people need to educate yourself if your gonna base a opinion i want all of the people who think i am wrong to visit a feed lot who feeds “corn” cause i am the only one who i really think has a hands on experience about this topic thanks everyone educate themselves! :)

  8. 炊飯器チーズケーキ
    If ifs and ands have been pots and pans there’d be no operate for tinkers

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s