COLONY COLLAPSE DISORDER increasing costs for farmers

Colony collapse disorder or CCD occurs when a bee colony collapses or fails due to the sudden disappearance of its worker bees. Bee colonies may be destroyed or may withdraw from a hive for a number of reasons. For example, Varroa mite infestations can be particularly destructive. However, the exact cause of CCD or “the mass disappearance of worker honey bees” is unknown. There are several theories to explain what’s causing CCD, but it probably results from a combination of factors. Though, there may be one or two factors—probably resulting from anthropogenic activities—which play a more prominent role in the manifestation of CCD. For instance, according to the Daily Green, bee frames, which house the honey, pollen, bee larva, and unhatched bee eggs, have “to be replaced every 2 or 3 years because of the agricultural toxins that build up inside.” More from the Washington Times:

The prevailing theory on the cause of CCD includes several factors. The three main suspects of CCD are: viruses, stress and pesticides. When joined together these factors may create the deadly disease, researchers say.

As a result of the increasing scarcity of bees and beekeepers, the cost of bee rental has skyrocketed. Farmers rent beehives to increase pollination thus crop productivity, so bees do more than just make honey—they’re important pollinators as well. According to estimates from a Cornell University study, “Nearly one-third of U.S. agriculture depends on the 2.4 million bee colonies for big crop production, where they annually pollinate $14 billion worth of seeds and crops.” More from Economist.com:

Since 2006, however, bees have been suffering from “colony collapse disorder” (CCD), a mysterious affliction that has drastically reduced their numbers. As a result, says Joe MacIlvaine, the president of Paramount Farming and the largest almond-grower in the world, the rental cost of a hive has tripled in the past five years to about $150. Bee rental now accounts for 15% of Paramount’s costs.

So Paramount has hired Mr Wardell, who has been studying bees for 30 years and CCD since it broke out. Its cause may be mobile-telephony radiation, viruses, fungi, mites and pesticides—or none of the above. In the absence of a clear explanation, Mr Wardell is concentrating on something different: nutrition.

A healthy worker bee spends about four weeks in its hive, feeding on protein-rich pollen and nursing larvae, and then another two weeks in the field eating sugary honey until its proteins are depleted and it dies. For some reason bees are getting too little protein in the hive, thus dying after only about four weeks, almost as soon as they venture outside. So Mr Wardell is force-feeding them protein. He owns a patent for MegaBee, which he says “looks like cookie dough”. He puts a bit of this into the hives, blocking the bees’ entrance so that they have to chomp their way through it. As part of his new job, Mr Wardell is working with beekeepers across the country to supplement bee diets everywhere.

So far he has noticed that hives are smaller this year and some colonies still collapsing. But he has hopes that his cookies will work, bringing more of a buzz next year.

In addition to nutritional issues, current research into a solution for CCD is focusing on breeding disease-resistant bees. From the Washington Times:

Through the growing science of genomics – the science of looking at molecular information in DNA – Mr. Delaplane’s science team will select a super-resistant bee that is able to naturally combat CCD and a culprit in this disorder: varroa mites.

First, “We’re going to be identifying bees that are resistant to XYZ” diseases, he said. Then, “We will be able to genetically mark these lines.”

The technique of marking and using favorable genetic traits is now done in the animal and plant industry, but marking a natural trait is different than engineering a change.

“We have no plan for doing [genetic] engineered selections,” Mr. Delaplane said. “We’re going to be screening for natural resistance.”

Afterward, Mr. Delaplane’s team will take those disease-resistant bees and breed more of them. Here science is guiding the process of natural selection.

Once the genetically strong bees are developed in the laboratory, they will be shipped to commercial bee breeders. The breeders, in turn, will mass produce them and flood the market with disease-resistant bees to beekeepers across the country. CCD may still be around, but the superbee’s immune system will effectively combat it.

Photo source for attribution here, here, here, here, here, here, and here. The authors or licensors of these images do not endorse my work or me and their images are protected under an attribution license. The bee graphic is via The New York Times.

add to del.icio.us :: Add to Blinkslist :: add to furl :: Digg it :: add to ma.gnolia :: Stumble It! :: add to simpy :: seed the vine :: :: :: TailRank :: post to facebook

Advertisement

4 thoughts on “COLONY COLLAPSE DISORDER increasing costs for farmers

  1. Malnutrition is criminally under-researched, so good on Paramount and Wardell for taking the initiative to study it. However supplementary feeding is not a sustainable solution to honeybee nutritional problems. If supplementary feeding becomes the standard response to CCD, it will be an admission that farming is ecologically bankrupt. Enough research has been done that shows that no one pollen source provides all the different amino acids needed for bee health. The real challenge is to get landowners to come on board and manage at least part of their land for pollinator, including honeybee, health and nutrition. This will mean more research will need to be done on what local plant species can together form a nutritionally balanced and complete “bee diet”. The focus of bee nutrition must be put back on the landscape, where it belongs. Supplementary feeding must remain exactly that: supplementary. Not replacement.

    • Thanks Phoebe for articulating the importance of nutrition in beekeeping and the importance of landscape over supplementary feeding.

  2. I know this is a dreadful problem but there are plenty of more reliable sources than the Washington Times to quote from Penn State Univ and the Mid-Atlantic Apiculture Society http://maarec.psu.edu/ColonyCollapseDisorder.html

    • Thank you for the information and your concern Dianne. If you’ve read something from the Washington Times report on CCD that isn’t reliable or incorrect, then please let me know. Likewise, if I’ve quoted something from this article that isn’t correct, then please let me know. My email address is above.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s